Score: 3

"The movie itself wasn't great"

submission: Magical Mystery Tour

date: August 24, 2009

The biggest problem is that nothing was actually "animated". You just tweened motion.

Of course, if you see any of my movies, I'm guilty of it too. 100%.

So who am I to judge?

I listened to the whole song too, because its superb.

Score: 10

"Great!"

submission: Shark Bat

date: August 22, 2009

I absolutely LOVE the sound the bat makes when it contacts the kid's head. There's nothing cartoony or overdone about it. It's just the sound of a hollow metal bat hitting something hard.

And those people who are whining over the kid being hit by a bat - get over it. We have kids getting shot out there in reality. Go help them if you're so righteous.

Score: 7

"You can feel the frustration"

submission: Cool Party! ! !

date: August 21, 2009

It's so David Lynch, but then you just get frustrated and turn it into black and white stick figures and squiggles - and when that happens, you can feel it. It comes across. My blood pressure is higher from watching this. Good job.

Score: 8

"Doesn't Foreman mean "Subdural hematoma"?"

submission: HOUSE MD animated

date: March 23, 2009

He says "subdermal hematoma", which would be a very roundabout way of saying "a bruise". I'm sure this is not what you intended in your script...a minor error.

Nontheless, good job!

Score: 5

"The art and coloring are both good..."

submission: Narwhals

date: March 23, 2009

...but the song annoys me to no end. I can only give this a five.

Score: 5

"Worker and Parasite?"

submission: Cloudwatchers

date: June 12, 2008

It's clear you were using a mouse to draw and not a tablet. However, you did a good job using only the mouse.

Now, I'm sure I'm not the only one who's going to be wondering WTF this movie is actually about. Really though, its kind of difficult to follow and has a sort of stereotypical Russian humour to it, like Worker and Parasite from the Simpsons.

Score: 2

"Piss-poor audio."

submission: Viagra?

date: June 12, 2008

The vocal clipping is horrible. Fix it.

Score: 9

"Music..."

submission: |~SpeedAnim:WheresWaldo~|

date: June 5, 2008

Did you compose the music to this?

If so, with what program?

Score: 3

"Osama bin robocop"

submission: ROBOCOP: Desktop Vigilant

date: June 2, 2008

So, this to me looked like an al-qaeda vid where robocop was holding superman hostage and demanding that the watchers of the video, presumingly americans, do something concerning the middle east that does not involve tanks and whores.

otherwise its pretty crappy.

Score: 7

"I really thought I was going to blam this..."

submission: A Walk in the Forest

date: June 2, 2008

But I was totally surprised.

The animation is ok, the art is passable although I despise stick-art, and the animation is somewhat poor. However, the concepts and atmosphere that you weave into your creation are charming, honestly.

I also really appreciate the perspective change during the falling scene - impressive.

Also, I think that the stickdude, although poorly animated overall, has excellent facial expressions.

Good job. Now buy an Intuos3 tablet and draw out your cartoons. You will do well.